Homebrewing: Jumping from Partial-Grain to All-Grain
Cats: Uncategorized| 1 Comment »Ok, Ok, I know it’s been forever since my last post and for that I apologize, but you know with summer comes distractions. Fortunately lots of my distractions have been beer related so I have plenty of stuff to back-cover here.
Homebrewers typically are very chill laid back people, but when you get down to it the best homebrews come from those who understand the fickle science of beer making the best. While there are many ways to classify and segment the types of homebrewers perhaps the most common is extract/partial-grain vs all-grain.
The All-Grain Brewer creates their pre-boil wort by first going through a “mashing” process to extract all of their fermentable sugars from the pounds of malted grain, like a full sized brewery.
The Extract or Partial-Grain Brewer creates most or all of their pre-boil wort by purchasing their fermentable sugars in syrup or dry powder form. This effectively allows them to skip the step of mashing their own grain.
In homebrewing there is a mantra that goes something like, “ sure, you don’t have to be an all-grain brewer to make great beers… you can make great extract beer, it’s done all the time” The homebrewing community understands that people want to wade into the hobby and extract brewing is a great way to do it. It’s kinda like saying you can be a great swimmer even if you never leave the shallow end, but here is my take:
I usually brew with my good friend Rob, after all what good is beer if you can’t share it with someone? We’re a couple of brews into the all-grain experience now and I can’t speak for him, but I wanted to step out of the partial-grain realm and into the all-grain realm for several reasons, but the greatest of those was that I thought that I could make better beer. It’s not that I’m not happy with the partial-grain brew that we had been producing, but something about it was bothering me. The beers, regardless of style, if we were using the same base malt extract something about the beer tended to taste the same. I thought with all-grain brewing we were offered the opportunity to create a more complex and oft more true-to-style base for the beer and so we made a mash-tun out of a broken cooler, some tubing and a filter and gave the great experiment a whirl.
After the first two experiments I’ve determined that I was right about one thing… we were able to make better beer, but I was wrong about why. As we delved into the all-grain adventure I had to do a lot of re-reading Joy of Homebrewing, I talked to other brewers, more advanced than I, I read segments from other books and online posts about all-grain recipes and process. Taking time to understand some of the major concepts in mashing helped me not only successfully make all-grain beer but also helped me identify what I was doing incorrectly when we were brewing with partial-grain. I could get into the specific issues but the important thing to take away was this: you can make great extract beer, but with partial-grain recipes, save the time by not doing the full mash, but don’t convince yourself, as I did, that you don’t need to take the time to understand the concepts of mashing.








